“I’ll keep renting and invest the deposit instead.” It sounds sensible. But how hard does that money need to work to beat owning your own home?
In this example, the answer is around 7.3% a year on the calculator’s investment-return setting. At 5%, buying comes out comfortably ahead. At 8%, renting and investing wins. Then one small change flips the answer again.
One home. Two choices.
Imagine you rent an apartment for AED 75,000 a year. A comparable home costs AED 1.2 million, and you expect to stay for ten years.
| Annual rent | AED 75,000, initially flat |
|---|---|
| Purchase price | AED 1,200,000 |
| Down payment | 20% |
| Mortgage | 4.2% over 25 years |
| Service charges + maintenance | AED 17,000 a year |
| Property growth | 2% a year |
| Comparison period | 10 years |
Buying needs approximately AED 334,000 upfront, including modelled fees. The mortgage is about AED 5,174 a month, or AED 6,591 including service charges and maintenance. Rent is AED 6,250 a month.
For a fair comparison, the renter starts with the same cash, pays the rental setup costs and invests the rest, plus the roughly AED 341 monthly saving. Both paths use the same monthly budget.
Change one thing. Change the winner.
1. Invest at 5%. Rent stays flat.
Buying leads by AED 143,261
2. Invest at 8%. Rent stays flat.
Rent & invest leads by AED 52,121
3. Invest at 8%. Rent rises 2% a year.
Buying leads by AED 36,858
Includes modelled buying costs, mortgage settlement and a 2% selling-agent fee plus VAT. Buyer figures are equity after sale and repayment of the remaining loan, not the property’s gross value. Illustrations, not forecasts.
At 5%, buying wins by around AED 143,000
The renter’s investments grow, but the buyer is also paying down a mortgage and building equity. With these assumptions, a 5% investment return does not keep up.
At 8%, renting wins by around AED 52,000
Keep everything else unchanged and increase the investment return to 8%. Now the renter comes out ahead. The break-even point is roughly 7.3%, provided rent stays flat and the money stays invested.
Let rent rise by 2%, and buying wins again
Keep that 8% investment return, but increase rent by 2% a year. Buying now leads by approximately AED 37,000.
As rent rises, the model gives the buyer the same higher monthly budget and uses any spare money to overpay the mortgage. That reduces the debt sooner. It assumes you actually make those extra repayments.
My takeaway: buying does not need spectacular property growth to be competitive. Here, renting needs an investment return in the 7–8% range just to compete while rent stays flat. That is a result for this example, not a universal rule for Dubai.
You also get a home that is yours.
For me, the appeal goes beyond a final number. You can settle in, make the place your own and plan around your family, rather than a landlord’s plans. Part of each mortgage payment reduces a debt on something you own.
If I can afford it comfortably, buy at a sensible price and expect to stay, I see owning as a practical way to build long-term wealth while meeting a need I already have: somewhere to live.
It is still an investment with risks. Prices can fall, mortgage rates and repair bills can rise, and selling takes time and money. Renting can be the better fit if you need flexibility or would be stretching yourself to buy.
The assumptions matter.
The 2% property growth, rent increases and 5% or 8% investment returns are assumptions, not promises. Lower property growth or higher ownership costs can favour renting. A better purchase price can favour buying.
See the calculation details
- Same starting cash: AED 333,750. Rental setup uses AED 5,250 agency fee and AED 3,750 refundable deposit, leaving AED 324,750 invested.
- Buying costs use 2% agency fee plus VAT, 4% DLD, AED 4,780 fixed charges, and mortgage fees of 1.3% of the loan plus AED 3,290. These are model inputs, not lender quotes.
- All three results include selling-agent fees of 2% plus VAT and mortgage settlement of 1% of the remaining loan, capped at AED 10,000, plus VAT.
- The monthly budget is the higher of rent or scheduled ownership costs. Renter savings are invested; buyer savings overpay the mortgage. Overpayment fees are assumed to be zero.
- Mortgage rate remains 4.2% throughout; service charges and maintenance remain constant. Real fixed-rate periods may be shorter.
- Annual investment inputs are divided by 12 and compounded monthly. The 5% and 8% settings correspond to about 5.12% and 8.30% effective annual growth. The 7.3% break-even setting is about 7.5% effective. Property and rent growth apply annually.
- Figures are nominal and exclude inflation adjustments, insurance, moving costs, investment fees and taxes. Returns are smooth in the model; actual markets fluctuate. Check your own tenancy before assuming rent increases.
What would your numbers say?
Start with your rent and a realistic purchase price. Try a 5% investment return, then 8%. Change the rent growth and see how much the result moves. That is far more useful than assuming either buying or renting always wins.
Want to work through your own rent-versus-buy decision?
I help everyday people understand the numbers and build a property plan around their finances and goals. We’re advisors, not estate agents.
Already own a home? Read how I used equity release to buy another Dubai property.
Calculated on 7 November 2026 using the current PropertyAdvice.ae Rent vs Buy model. Educational illustrations, not guaranteed returns or personalised advice.
Further reading: Understanding investment performance claims and the DLD rental index.
Share this guide on WhatsApp